Proposition · Chain 128/192
PROT18.4
Social Coherence Monitoring
Knowledge
🧪 Protocol
7Q
None
9
Bridges
Material
Category
🧪 Protocol
Domain
silver
Status
None
Collapse Radius
—
Physics
—
Theology
—
Scripture
—
Kills
Judge & Jury
Claims
Protocol: Measure discontinuity in conversion events.
Identity
Formal
Formal Statement
Measure discontinuity in conversion events This protocol tests whether religious/spiritual conversion events show coherence discontinuities (phase transitions) rather than gradual change: - Gradual…
Plain English
In Plain Words
Why This Type
Classification
Formal Architecture
Equation 1
$$C(t) = \begin{cases} C_1 & t < t_c \\ C_2 & t \geq t_c \end{cases}$$Equation 2
$$\frac{dC}{dt} < \infty \text{ for all } t$$Equation 3
$$\lim_{t \to t_c^-} C(t) \neq \lim_{t \to t_c^+} C(t)$$+29 more equations
Objections & Defense
Objection
Conversion Is Subjective
"Conversion is a subjective experience. There's no objective moment of conversion, so testing for discontinuity at 't_c' is meaningless." Response: Subjectivity doesn't preclude objectivity: 1.
Objection
Small Sample Bias
"Conversion experiences are rare and highly individual. A small sample can't support general claims about conversion dynamics." Response: Sample size considerations: 1.
Objection
Discontinuities Are Psychological, Not Physical
"Any observed discontinuity is psychological—a change in self-concept or narrative—not a physical phase transition in any meaningful sense." Response: The distinction may be artificial: 1. Mind-Brain…
Collapse Analysis
Collapse Radius: None
If PROT18.4 finds only continuous change: - Conversion is gradual, not phase transition - Theophysics must revise phase transition claims - Spiritual development may be more like skill learning than state change - Grace may work gradually rather than discretely - Conversion is a genuine phase transition - Theophysics' physical model of conversion supported - Stability of conversion may relate to depth of phase transition - Practical implications for ministry, therapy, spiritual direction - PROT18.5 (Phi-Virtue Correlation) proceeds regardless - Results inform interpretation but don't determine downstream protocols - Both outcomes advance understanding of spiritual change Collapse Radius: MODERATE - Affects conversion theology but not core framework > [!abstract]- Canonical Navigation > - Global Consciousness Project > - Ten Laws — Canonical Equations > - Master Equation Index ---
Snapshot
Formal Statement
Measure discontinuity in conversion events This protocol tests whether religious/spiritual conversion events show coherence discontinuities (phase transitions) rather than gradual…
Plain English